ClearMint vs YNAB
YNAB suits people who want a proven zero-based method that gives every dollar you already have a job. ClearMint is a smart spreadsheet for your finances: import statements, keep line-by-line detail and project balances 12 months ahead from expected income and bills.
At a glance
Two philosophies
YNAB budgets only money you already have, following its four rules. ClearMint plans with expected income and bills, and shows where balances are headed.
Imports
Both import files: YNAB takes OFX, QFX, QIF and CSV on the web; ClearMint takes OFX, QFX, CSV and PDF.
Sharing
YNAB Together lets up to six people share one subscription with their own logins. ClearMint households also have separate sign-ins, with Editor or Viewer roles.
Trial
YNAB's trial is 34 days with no credit card when you sign up on its site. ClearMint's is 30 days, with payment details taken at checkout.
ClearMint Essentials and YNAB, side by side
Both are budgeting tools; the differences are in method, imports and planning horizon.
| What you're comparing | ClearMint Essentials | YNAB |
|---|---|---|
| Price | CA$7.99/month or CA$79/year (prices in Canadian dollars). | US$109/year or US$14.99/month, plus tax where applicable. College students can get a free year. |
| Free trial | 30 days with every feature. Payment details are taken at checkout; you aren't charged until the trial ends and can cancel before then at no cost. | 34 days; no credit card required when you sign up on YNAB's site (app stores may ask for one). |
| Approach | Track what happened, plan what's coming: budgets plus a 12-month balance forecast built from expected income and bills. | Zero-based: give every dollar a job, embrace your true expenses, roll with the punches and age your money. You budget money you already have, not money you expect. |
| Platforms | Web app in any modern browser on desktop, tablet or phone. No native iOS or Android app. | Web, iOS and Android. |
| Getting transactions in | OFX, QFX, CSV and PDF statements, plus manual entry. The import preview flags likely duplicates (same bank transaction ID, or same date, amount and payee) and skips them by default. PDF results depend on the statement layout, so review them before importing. | Direct import from selected US, Canadian, UK and EU banks; unlinked accounts with manual entry; OFX, QFX, QIF and CSV file import on the web. |
| Recurring items | Recurring income, bills and subscriptions on weekly to yearly schedules, with suggestions found in your transactions and a flag when a charge differs from the usual amount. | Scheduled transactions from daily to every other year. |
| Planning ahead | 12-month forward cash-flow forecast from your balances, recurring income, bills and card payments, with the lowest projected balance highlighted. | Targets and scheduled transactions; Loan Planner for debt payoff (web). Balance forecast: not confirmed in the reviewed documentation. |
| Household access | Invite people by email to one shared household on one plan. Each person signs in with their own account as an Editor or Viewer; the owner and admins manage access. | YNAB Together: invite up to five people (six in total) on one subscription, each with their own login. |
| Net worth | Net worth from your accounts, cards and loans plus property and investment values you enter yourself. No investment holdings sync or portfolio analysis. | Net Worth report; YNAB recommends tracking investment accounts as unlinked accounts. |
| Export | CSV exports (transactions, budget, balance sheet, monthly account activity) and a full JSON backup, any time. | Export plan and transaction history as CSV files (web), plus a public API. |
Which one fits you?
Why choose ClearMint
- You want to see months ahead. The 12-month forecast shows your lowest projected balance, including card payments and irregular bills.
- You'd rather not adopt a method. Import a statement and your numbers are there; no assigning every dollar before you can see the picture.
- PDF statements. ClearMint can read PDF statements when a CSV or OFX file isn't available.
- Viewer access. Invite someone who can see your household's numbers without editing them.
When YNAB may suit you better
- You want a proven method. YNAB's four rules and teaching resources help many people change how they spend.
- You want native mobile apps. YNAB has iOS and Android apps; ClearMint is a web app.
- You budget only money you have. If you don't want expected income in your plan, YNAB's model fits that by design.
- You want a longer, card-free trial. YNAB's 34-day trial needs no card when you sign up directly.
Moving from YNAB to ClearMint
YNAB exports your plan and transaction history as CSV files from the web app. ClearMint imports CSV.
- In YNAB on the web, export your plan data; you'll get a plan file and a transactions file.
- In ClearMint, create your accounts and cards, then import the transactions CSV (one account at a time works best).
- Review the preview: likely duplicates are flagged and skipped by default.
- Set category budgets in ClearMint and add your recurring income and bills so the forecast fills in.
What won't transfer: YNAB's category assignments, targets, Age of Money and scheduled transactions. ClearMint doesn't use zero-based assignment, so rebuild budgets as category limits.
Questions about switching
More answers in the help centre or write to support.
What is YNAB's method?
YNAB is zero-based: you give every dollar you already have a job, plan for true (irregular) expenses, adjust when plans change, and aim to spend money that's at least 30 days old. It budgets money you have, not money you expect.
How is ClearMint different?
ClearMint keeps a detailed ledger from your statements and projects balances 12 months ahead from expected income, bills and card payments. You can set category budgets, but there's no requirement to assign every dollar.
Can both import bank files?
Yes. YNAB imports OFX, QFX, QIF and CSV on the web. ClearMint imports OFX, QFX, CSV and PDF.
Can my partner join?
Yes in both. YNAB Together allows up to six people on one subscription with separate logins. ClearMint lets you invite household members by email as Editors or Viewers.
How much does YNAB cost?
YNAB lists US$109 a year or US$14.99 a month, plus tax where applicable, with a 34-day free trial. ClearMint is CA$79 a year or CA$7.99 a month with a 30-day trial.
Keep exploring
Try ClearMint free for 30 days
Import a statement, review it like a spreadsheet and see the months ahead. Every feature included; prices in CAD.
Sources and last checked
Last checked October 12, 2026 on YNAB's official website and help pages. Features, plans, prices and availability change — confirm the details on the official site before you decide. ClearMint details reflect the current product.
- YNAB: Pricing (www.ynab.com/pricing)
- YNAB: Features (www.ynab.com/features)
- YNAB: YNAB Together (subscription sharing) (www.ynab.com/features/subscription-sharing)
- YNAB: File-based import (www.ynab.com/whats-new/file-based-import-elevated)
- YNAB: The YNAB method (www.ynab.com/ynab-method)
- YNAB support: Exporting plan data (support.ynab.com/en_us/how-to-export-plan-data-Sy_CouWA9)
ClearMint Essentials is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by YNAB. This is an independent comparison written by the ClearMint team; product names and trademarks belong to their owners. Spot something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.